The Atlanta Fed's macroblog provides commentary and analysis on economic topics including monetary policy, macroeconomic developments, inflation, labor economics, and financial issues.

Authors for macroblog are Dave Altig, John Robertson, and other Atlanta Fed economists and researchers.

« Abnormal consumer spending—not quite | Main | The undocumented and business survival in the United States »

April 24, 2009

Is the investment trend in the current recession “run of the mill”?

In the last macroblog post, David Altig examined personal consumption expenditures during recessionary periods. Reader Dave Backus, the Heinz Riehl Professor of International Economics and Finance at New York University's Stern School of Business, sent us a follow-up email asking about other components of gross domestic product, and investment in particular. Good question, so let's take a look at investment during the current and past recessions.

Earlier this year, the University of Chicago's Casey Mulligan, writing in the New York Times' Economix blog, examined real investment trends for the past four recessions and called the current investment trend in this recession "run of the mill." Employing the same basic idea from our previous macroblog post, below is a chart showing the percentage change from the first quarter to the trough of the last eight recessions, along with the percentage change from the current recession's first quarter to the first quarter of this year.


Prof. Mulligan's point emerges pretty clearly. Matched up against previous recessions, there is nothing spectacularly unusual about the declines in overall investment expenditure—not yet, at any rate. But that picture may be a bit deceiving. Here's the same sort of graph for fixed investment—that is, all investment expenditures other than changes in inventories.


The current recession—which is not yet over as far as we know—does not stack up so favorably when it comes to fixed investment spending. In fact it leads the pack in terms of investment decline among the eight recessions since 1960. This fact is not too surprising given the the relative impact of residential private investment in the current recession. This impact can be seen by comparing gross domestic private investment with gross domestic private investment excluding residential private investment. In all previous recessions apart from 1990, the percentage change in gross domestic private investment excluding residential private investment significantly exceeds the drop in gross private investment, and in the 1990 recession they were roughly comparable. In the current recession, gross domestic private investment excluding residential investment is significantly less than the gross domestic private investment.


In addition to that difference, the comparison of gross investment patterns is significantly affected by the behavior of inventory changes across recessions. The modest decline in overall inventories in the current downturn is the reason for the relatively benign view of investment highlighted in Casey Mulligan's Economix piece.


So, let's consider again whether the current investment trend in this recession is "run of the mill." Perhaps at first glance it is, but when we break down the components of gross domestic private investment, these charts inform us that the relative declines in the various components of gross domestic private investment are quite different in this recession. And just how benign that picture is depends, in part, on whether the slow pace of inventory decumulation thus far proves a lasting feature of this recession. On that, we will just have to wait and see.

By Courtney Nosal, economic research analyst at the Atlanta Fed

April 24, 2009 in Business Cycles , Data Releases | Permalink


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to blogs that reference Is the investment trend in the current recession “run of the mill”? :


How much of the change in behavior of inventories can be attributed to 'just in time' efficiencies in inventory management that have caused the overall size of inventories to shrink?
My ad hoc analysis is that business investment has been depressed since the dotcom bust, so the decline for this current downturn is not from a robust base and so may not be comparable to previous recessions.

Posted by: don | April 24, 2009 at 04:29 PM

Can you add the chart for nonresidential fixed investments?

This is the category many think of when you are discussing investment.

Posted by: spencer | April 24, 2009 at 05:27 PM

Could you add a chart of non-residential fixed investment to the article.

That is what most people think of when you discuss investments.

Posted by: spencer | April 25, 2009 at 07:53 AM

If you look at the change in the capital stock this recession is also very different and much worse. In 2009 we will have the capital stock declining for the first time since the 1930s. That is in part because the net investment rate did not get very high during the expansion--despite all of the investment friendly tax cuts (partial expensing reduced rates on capital gains and dividends.

Posted by: rana | April 25, 2009 at 01:45 PM

Not only was investment's decline from a low base, a larger than usual share of the investment that comprised that low base was in commercial real estate rather than in manufacturing or natural resource development. What investment was directed to manufacturing by domestic corporations in recent years was disproportionately directed overseas. These circumstances augur poorly for domestic employment recovery.

Posted by: mrrunangun | April 25, 2009 at 02:03 PM

Just wanted to say HI. I found your blog a few days ago and have been reading it over the past few days.

Posted by: runescape money | April 27, 2009 at 02:08 AM

Could you add a chart of non-residential fixed investment to the article.

That is what most people think of when you discuss investments.

Posted by: runescape power leveling | May 31, 2010 at 09:05 PM

Post a comment

Comments are moderated and will not appear until the moderator has approved them.

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign in

Google Search

Recent Posts



Powered by TypePad